Welcome to Pizza Delivery! Log in or Join the community.
Rating:
Based on: 22 reviews
RATE IT
MATTHEW'S PIZZARIA
3131 EASTERN AVE,
Baltimore, Maryland 21224
(410) 276-8755

About Us: Matthew's Pizza is proud to be Baltimore's First Pizzeria and with numerous awards and rave reviews, they can claim that their pizza is the best in the world. They created different varieties of pizza from their famous Crab Pie, No Cheese and Three Cheese Pie that get the locals and tourists crave for another serving. Family dinner and celebrations become a fun and enjoyable family reunions amidst the serving of their delicious pasta, appetizers, salad and desserts that are so irresistible like the Cheesecake and Homemade Gelato and Sorbetta.


Last updated 8.9.2011

Reservations Policy: None

Ambiance: Casual, Family Friendly

Menu: balti, french toast, bruschetta, french fries, cannoli, greek salad, spinach salad, garlic bread, italian pie, italian pizza, antipasto salad, deep dish pizza, tomato pie, white pizza, cheese pizza

Cuisine: Pizza

Dress Code: Casual

Brands: Mastercard

Specialties Other: Mastercard

Price: $0 - $10

Feature: Private Rooms, Take Out

Keywords: Carry Out & Take Out, Restaurants, American Restaurants, Pizza

Amenities: Kid-Friendly

Reviews (22) Write a review

Posted by
Kara
11/24/2005

Supposed to the the best.....: Now this is just an opinion... but venders took me there... and said... the best pizza ever. This is so good. Actually I have had better. The service was not the best. And the pizza tasted burnt on bottom and quite not the best cheese and tomato topping.

Posted by
Andrea Donnells
05/10/2008

Being from NY, it is tough to find a pizza joint in Baltimore, but this is the best pizza south of the Mason Dixon. From the old italian home decor to the magnificient staff, a must try if your in the Baltimore Area. I recommend the mushroom and meatball pie or the crab pie


Posted by
I.M.A.Q.T
02/04/2006

MATTHEW`S PIZZA [THE BEST PIZZA IN BALTIMORE]: I HAD THE BEST PIZZA AT MATTHEW`S THEY USE REAL TOMATOS FOR THE PIZZA SAUSE THE CHEESE THEY USE IN INPORTED THE FINEST AND YOU CAN TELL THE DIFFERENT`S IN THE PIZZA ,THEY ALSO OFFER DIFFERENT KINDS OF PIZZA ,A GOOD CHANGE FROM THE SAME OLD PIZZA AND HAVE ALOT OF GREAT TOPPINGS.IF YOU ARE EVER IN BALTIMORE GIVE MATTHEW`S PIZZA A TRY.


Posted by
Jeanne Michele
04/02/2009

Matthew's is by far and away a great pizza, if not one of the best kind's of pizza I have ever eaten. But those not from the region need to understand that this is not New York or Chicago or Italian Pizza. It is a very distinct Baltimore pie. Trying to compare it to anything else is going to lead to disappointment. Open your mind and mouth and enjoy.


Posted by
redstormleigh
12/05/2005

The Best Pizza Ever: The pizzas there are called pies. They are huge and are deep like pies. They put a lot of cheese and any other toppings you might like on. They are very reasonably priced, and have great service. If you like quality and quanity in a nice atmosphere I would suggest that you go here.


Posted by
Brian
02/16/2008

Don't believe the hype. The crust is underdone, almost like french toast. It is extremely greasy. It also has a slightly sour taste, like bad milk. It reminds me of pizza from costco or sams club.

Posted by
a Yahoo! Local User
11/24/2006

Greasy deep dish: If you like a New York type slice, crispy and thin then this is not the pizza for you. It's more like Chicago style, but honestly it reminded me of very very greasy Pizza hut pizza. It's OK but definitely not great.

Posted by
a Yahoo! Local User
02/10/2007

The BEST Pizza: I've had pizza all over the US and Italy, if you don't like this pizza then you don't really like pizza. By far the best in Bmore, but overall just plain good pizza.

Posted by
969687
12/08/2008

not the best pizza. small and very bland very small pizzeria.

Posted by
a Yahoo! Local User
02/10/2007

2 Generations: My mom took me there when I was a kid. She told me it was the best pizza ever. 43 years later I've introduces dozens of people to the fantastic round and very different taste that is truly exquisite.

Posted by
cthomp12002
02/18/2009

I take all my out-of-town guests here. This is the best pizza around, hands down. Very Baltimore too.

Posted by
a Yahoo! Local User
08/05/2004

Attorney: The best pizza you can buy.

Posted by
ablots
07/23/2008

My mom and dad took us to Mathews as a treat when we went to Baltimore to shop. That was 55+ years ago. I'm in NC now and when I get back to MD, I always try to get to Mathews.

Posted by
PizzaLover
09/02/2008

There is no comparison anywhere o n earth to compare to this Pizza. It is the best on the planet. Anyone disagreeing has bad taste buds. I am from East Baltimore, now live in Ocean City, and just wished we had a matthews here.

Posted by
chow.com
09/12/2007

Matthew's Pizza 3131 Eastern Ave. Baltimore MD (410) 276-8755 www.matthewspizza.com (this might not be the real deal but is very close to it)

Posted by
Christen
08/25/2011

Not impressed.I was traveling to Baltimore on business and visiting some local sites for happy hour in the Fell's Point area. When it came time for dinner I asked the bartender and some locals to recommend a good local pizza place - they all suggested Matthew's. I hadn't eaten in over six hours so I was not only starving but also craving my favorite food pizza. Now I'm from the Midwest but travel nationally and frequently. I eat pizza 2-3 times a week and love ALL types of pizza styles toppings you name it - especially local hot-spots. I thought Matthew's would be a jackpot since it was ranked as the top pizza place in Maryland. I was extremely disappointed upon trying Matthew's. It was no better than a frozen pie from the grocery store. It's a sad day when a pizza-fanatic prefers Matthew's salad to their

Posted by
citypaper.com
04/11/2007

Spaghetti served plain with Matthew's fresh and thick tomato sauce ($4.95) or topped with sausage veal chicken or homemade meatballs ($7.50) or shrimp ($8.95) is artlessly good perfect takeout fare. Salads are served with that...

Posted by
harlyman
03/27/2011

I love it. Don't change a thing...........

Posted by
JKIDD
06/19/2008

THE BEST PIZZA AROUND. THE TRADITIONAL PIZZA IS MY FAVORITE. I HAVE EATEN MATTHEW'S PIZZA SINCE I WAS A CHILD STARTING WITH THE ORIGINAL OWNER. THE QUALITY IS THE SAME IF NOT BETTER. KEEP UP THR GOOD WORK!

Posted by
SS-4
08/01/2006

Best homemade pizza in Baltimore excellent sauce their tomato and grated cheese pie is the best.

Posted by
Tracy H.
01/05/2009

Matthew's is in a category unto itself. It's really hard to compare it to other local pizza places since it's very different. Their thick crust is so perfectly greasy and crispy and chewy all at once but in a good way! Both Cheese is my favorite! Definitely a pizza to eat right away however. It's not as good if it's not fresh out of the oven.

Posted by
yellowpages.com
10/20/2006

Okay maybe if it was so wonderful as people have raved maybe it would be worth it. Well we got it home and the crust was so underdone as to almost be uncooked. The dough was so undercooked that the pizza was entirably inedibale. Given...

View Larger Map / Get Directions