Absolutely wonderful! Wish I was still in college so I could get a slice between classes.

BEST PIZZA IN GAINESVILLE, HANDS DOWN: IF YOU'VE EVER TASTED REAL NY PIZZA, THIS IS THE CLOSEST THING YOU'LL FIND TO THAT IN ALL OF FLORIDA. SOLD BY THE SLICE OR WHOLE PIES, CRISPY THIN LIGHT CRUST, AWESOME SAUCE AND CHEESE - ALL QUALITY INGREDIENTS

2 years away from gville, still miss this place!: This was THE best pizza I'd had in Florida. Also - on tuesdays, they would make these amazing meatball subs - don't know if they still make em or not? If they do, you have to try them.

THE best pizza anywhere. I remember the meatbal subs too, and they were delicious, I worked there for a little while and lived for Tuesdays! I have moved from g-ville SIX years ago and i still miss it too.

This is the real thing!!!!: Eat your heart out-- this is the real thing only in Florida... best of the best like the NYC pizzareias!!!! 6 stars..

This is a hole in the wall place but the pizza is great and the slices are huge! It's walking distance from campus so it's a good lunch place if the weather is nice since there's no seating. It's also good after football games because it's close to the stadium but the line can get super long right after games.

This is literally one of the best pizza restaurants that I have ever been to in my entire life. The restaurant itself is nothing fancy literally a hole in the wall! The location is right across from UF campus. Whenever I return to UF as an alumn I will always have a slice of pizza from Italian Gator Pizza! EVERYONE NEEDS TO TRY ITALIAN GATOR PIZZA!