I grew up in Lancaster and Fat Cat was by far the best around. I moved away for a few years and to my surprise when I came back Mrs. Casto had sold the business. I gave it a try anyways. It is still good but not close to the way it was. The crust does not have the same taste and the cheese is different. What made this place the greatest was the mixture of the crust cheese and their sauce. The new owners have also cut back on the amount of toppings. It is a shame because I wouldn't mind driving 30 mins to get. Maybe with enough complaints the Blankenships would pay Mrs. Casto a consulting fee.

Pretty darn good. Ignore the rant someone posted. I had no issues; the service was good as was the pizza. From what I can tell there are 3 of these in Lancaster this address the one labeled

Fat Cat Pizza East is still our #1 choice for delivery. Their quality brings us back on a regular basis.