Would not return..... Service was terrible - took over 10 minutes to have order taken and the pizza was burnt around the edges. Not impressed at all.

Just returned to Milwaukee,first plan was to go out for pizza at the Olive Pit......OMG their closed! NUTS! Was really looking forward to a carmalized onion pizza. Now I find they closed the doors on the business, NUTS! This was one of our fav spots,...a sad day.

Had pizza lastnight, excellent, the service is not that great, considering there was one other table by the time our pizza came. I will definitely eat there again.

Great neighborhood casual pizza joint with super nice owners! - bestwineguy - Sep-26-2009

Decent place similar to Transfer pizza in it's style location and menu which is not as extensive as Transfer. We had the cowboy pizza gluten free and it was very good. Also had garden and Caesar salad which were also good. I would agree w some others and say the service definitely needs improvement. Our waitress (who didn't write anything down) asked for our drink order than had to return 5 minutes later to ask what we wanted again. Also got our pizza order wrong and looked surprised when we requested in be corrected (it didn't have sausage and just asked some be cooked and thrown on top). The order finally was corrected and then the bill came which was also wrong. Ultimately everything was corrected and overall the experience was fine. I recommend trying it for yourself to at least get a taste for their delicious pizza. Food-B+ location - C+ service - C- - Deuce - Aug-06-2011

The Fresh Everything looked great with thinly sliced tomato fresh mozzarella and fresh basil sprinkled over before serving but the crust wasn't crisp. - jsonline.com - Sep-19-2008

marcheses Rehorst Vodka sauce this week!! YUM!! Mention Facebook and get $2 off your pasta order! http://bit.ly/bzPG8246 days agoreply - milwaukeefood.com - Oct-29-2007

The Mushroom and the Pesto pizza came without Olive Pit's red sauce and were a bit bland for our carnivorous tastes but the crust here is good and we could tell the toppings were fresh; to us they would be a good reorder option for an - onmilwaukee.com - Apr-23-2007

My party of three arrived at 8:00 pm on Saturday 7-24 and were told the wait was 45 minutes to an hour. Little did we know they were referring to the pizza not the table. Within nanoseconds a table of 4 in the bar area got up and left meaning we could sit down within 5 minutes of our arrival.... - SkiKingMKE - Jul-24-2010