Got to add my compliments to the great food here. I had the personal supreme pizza which was perfect for one hungry person. I only wish I had company so I could have tried those garlic knots some other review had bragged about. The ingredients tasted very fresh and the crust was delicious. Maybe not the best pizza ever, but it definately ranks. Of course the homage to the NYY and their little league team also named the Yanks are pretty nice. The music gives a nice atmosphere as well. Only bad part was the few shady characters hanging around in the shopping center at 9pm.

Awesome Pizza: The service is spectacular and their pizza is great. They sell pizza by the slice. Try their cheese pizza, it's incredible.

LOVE it...Even if: Love the place, love the food even if they are rude there. They can be...it is NEW YORK style pizza and resturant. We eat there at least once a week. They know where to deliver just by our phone number. LOVE IT. Food is great, large portions and at reasonable prices.

Best NY Style Pizza in C.FL.: Hands-down, the best NY Style pizza you can get. You know a place is good when it's packed, and this place is ALWAYS PACKED. The only reason I gave Ambiance a score of "4" is because the place is just way too small - not enough room for all the people wanting to eat there! Not unusual to wait at least 30 minutes for a table to clear, and sometimes it can get loud. Great place to kick back, relax, and enjoy a great pizza with friends and family. If there's one thing I DEFINITELY recommend from their menu is the garlic knots - OH MY GOD, YOU MUST HAVE THE GARLIC KNOTS! You won't regret it ;)

Great Place: This is a great restaurant for true authentic italian food. Be sure to try their stromboli. Extended delivery area works out nice too.

This is possibly the best pizza ever.: GREAT New York style, huge foldable slices, with tons of cheese. Their toppings are always fresh. AWESOME pizza...

I've been eating pizza at Goodfella's since the first week they were open because I'm lucky enough to live just down the street from them. I have heard over and over from people who come into the restaurant how authentic their pizza is to the pizza in New York. I wouldn't know because I've only been to New York once and wasn't really very thrilled with the slices I ate in Manhattan. What I can say is that Goodfellas is the best pizza I've ever had in my entire life. Their cheeses are the highest quality available and their crust is so perfect, I don't even know how to describe it. A must try is their Margherita pizza, this is basically a pizza with little to no sauce, just fresh cheese, sliced tomatoes and tons of fresh cut up basil. If the flavors don't make an addict out of you, the smell certainly will! If I hadn't just had three slices of it, I'd be craving it again right now just thinking about it! Long live Goodfellas!!

We can't wait to go back: We can't wait to go back

Looked online and it is true! A real gem!: I found this place online. I am from California. Best NY sytle pizza I ever ate and I lived in New Jersey. The crust alone is worth the price!! Friendly and always smiling. Service was quick yet nice! Great cold beer! I ate there twice it was so fantastic! There is a waiting list but it is fast. You simply cannot find better pizza!

Excellent pizza and garlic knots. The family all decided to try something different on the menu... BIG MISTAKE!!! Chicken marsala looked boiled and was very bland, baked trio was terrible.. how can you mess up ravioli and manicotti. My kids had spaghetti the sauce was all watery I didn't blame them for not eating it. Pizza yes anything else a big no no.

Great Pizza: I've never had a bad meal here. The pizza is the best in the UCF area, chicken marsala is wonderful, salads are large. It's clean, and service is always fast and friendly.

The Best Pizza In Orlando, Hands Down!!!: You must try this pizza, I have been hooked for years. Its so good youll get fat.

This Place Is The Best In The UCF area: Aside from all of the Yankees memorabilia on the walls (as a Red Sox fan), this is an awesome place. The garlic knots are rediculous, dip them in some of the alfredo and marinara and you are in heaven. My fav is the chicken parm sub, but you're likely to love anything you eat at this place.

By Far...: The Best Pizza in Town...A Place where flavors meet with great customer service...The Best Pizza in Town!!!

My whole family is originally from New York and we all agree this is hands down the best pizza in Orlando. If you like New York style pizza make your way to the east side of town out by UCF on Colonial and Alafaya. It's a great place to take the family or just run in for take out.

Best Pizza, very New York!: I really like the pizza at Goodfella's pizza. it's hard to find good pizza in Orlando. I am from New York and I love some pizza. Goodfella's has a great ambiance with pictures of New York and Scarface, etc. They have some great lunch specials.

great place: I go there once every 2 weeks with friends so we can catch up on eathother, enjoy amazing food and we watch pool while we eat. By the way i sometimes drive by to skip traffic and smell whats up by goodfella's. (the oroma is to die for)

The best: The best food in Orlando,MUST TRY THE GARLIC KNOTS TO DIED FOR .ALL FOOD IS EXCELLANT

Goodfellas......Great food: I Live 15minutes from this restaurant & it's worth the time traveling there. Finding an Italian Resaurant that cooks Pasta/Pizza/Veal/Chicken/Seafood well is VERY hard....this is one that does. Service / Seating has gotten better since they have expanded. Price is very reasonable

The best Italian in Orlando!: Why pay more? The service is great, the food is consistently delicious and you can't beat the prices!

Pizza Lovers Paradise: Great little pizza place located by UCF. The pizza tastes about as good as your gonna get in Florida. Recommend to anyone who is a true pizza lover.

Does it taste good!: Real, real pizza and spaghetti with that delicious homey taste......and they deliver! The best in East Orlando.

"I've been eatin at Goodfella's for 7 years. Great food great service." "Best pizza and garlic knots in town" Oh and the calamari................

Best pizza! Reasonably priced, good atmosphere, good service! What more can you ask for in a pizzeria! Highly recommended!!!!

A family owned great Italian eatery: Goodfellas is a place I eat at weekly because of how good the food is. I love the Hawaiian Stromboli and I get the large because I'd rather have some for later.

Best Pizza in Orlando!: Let's face it, good New York style pizza is hard to find in Orlando. This is the only place that comes close. We eat there at least once a week.

Good stuff!!: My family loves the fried calamari! We've never had dinner there we usually order take-out about once a month. So far everything is good. The staff is polite and the service is prompt.

best pizza in town with great prices!

I've eaten at Goodfella's several times for lunch and would recommend it! They have lunch specials. Their pizza is wonderful and this is coming from a

This is one of the best places for pizza in East Orlando. Whenever we want a great pizza to go we get it here.As a restaurant it's not bad but not particularly good. The prices are reasonable and the servers are nice. But the food is nothing special.

Hard to watch your calories when you order a pizza from Goodfellas! I have only gotten take-out and am always greeted by name when I walk in the door. The staff is very friendly there may be a long wait but the wait is definately worth it! I've watched them make the pies and unlike most places they do NOTskimp on cheese which is honestly what make the pizza. Toppings are the right amount and pies are cooked perfectly.

Definitely the best pizza in East Orlando!!!!

We compare any pizza we try to Goodfella's. It is awesome and we usually eat there at least once a week. Actually everything I have ever eaten there is awesome! Good for lunch or dinner or anytime!